Comments on: Plates of Honor

By: Nick Houtman

Nick Houtman — Wed, 13 Jun 2012 20:22:29 +0000

Well said, Eric. I wrote the headline, and, yes, I thought it might generate some discussion. Since Green herself uses the word “honor” in describing her motivation for this project, I think the headline captures the spirit the story. The deeper question is whether we can honor the humanity of people who have done terrible things. When people commit acts that lead to obvious, intentional suffering and deprive others of life, have they lost their humanity? Do they forfeit the right to live? After being killed by the state, do they deserve any recognition as human beings, let alone an act that honors their memory? Each person may answer in a way consistent with his or her beliefs, but these old questions still divide us, as the struggle with the death penalty demonstrates.

By: Eric Meslow

Eric Meslow — Tue, 12 Jun 2012 19:39:39 +0000

I enjoyed the article and although I have little talent myself…I do appreciate the skills and passion of others. I can easily find myself both artistically and emotionally siding with your expression. What I find unacceptable however is the use of the word “honor”. Perhaps it was your intent to stir the pot, to start a dialogue, but I find the very idea of “honoring” any of these criminals a tall order. At the minimum most were put to death for murder, many more for horrific crimes leadings up to that ultimate selfish act. Murder is a act / crime that hurts family, friends, and the entire community in which it occurs……..something that deserves absolutely the opposite of honoring.

honor
1. honesty, fairness, or integrity in one’s beliefs and actions: a man of honor.
2. a source of credit or distinction: to be an honor to one’s family.
3. high respect, as for worth, merit, or rank: to be held in honor.
4. such respect manifested: a memorial in honor of the dead.
5. high public esteem; fame; glory: He has earned his position of honor.

By: Jane Hamilton

Jane Hamilton — Wed, 06 Jun 2012 16:41:51 +0000

We have known Julie was artistic since as a 4-year old she drew pictures of people with buttons and buttonholes on their clothing and a smile face on the sun –long before smile face became common. She’s come a long way,baby!

By: Ingrid Lohman

Ingrid Lohman — Wed, 30 May 2012 13:58:58 +0000

Hi Julie: Congratulations on this article and video – hope all is well – sounds
like you are enjoying your garden and all the spring and summer has to bring.
I just bought a book on the fraud involved in olive oil – it is called “Extra Virginity”
by Tom Mueller – I plan to do alot of cooking when we get to Bozeman after
Steve’s retirement in a few weeks. Greta’s wedding was this past weekend -
all went beautifully. Also bought a book called “Quiet” which I have not started
yet, about shy vs. bold individuals and what Harvard business school is teaching
their grad students. Should be interesting. Have a great summer – say hi to Clay
for us. Lovingly, ingrid