Ethics
and Power in Mediation
A COMM 444/544 presentation
Gregg Walker, Ph.D., Professor
Oregon State University
Many of the ideas in this presentation
are adapted from the work of John “Sam” Keltner and his book, The Management
of Struggle (1994).
Dr. Keltner, OSU Professor Emeritus
of Speech Communication, developed this course at Oregon State University
Ethical Principles for Mediators
-
The parties in conflict have the primary responsibility
for the resolution of their dispute.
-
The mediator is to assist the parties in reaching
agreement.
-
The parties should determine the nature of
the intervention (e.g., mediation, arbitration).
Ethical Principles for Mediators
-
The mediator should be able to provide the
parties with procedural and substantive suggestions to assist them in reaching
an agreement.
-
Both (all) parties need to accept the mediator.
-
A mediator should not enter any dispute that
is being mediated by someone else.
Ethical Principles for Mediators
-
Mediators should not use their position for
private gain or advantage.
-
Mediators should avoid any appearance of disagreement
or criticism of fellow mediators.
-
Mediators should not place pressure on the
parties that may jeopardize voluntary decision-making.
Ethical Principles for Mediators
-
Mediators should maintain confidentiality
regarding disputant statements, behaviors, and interaction.
-
Mediators should gain the parties’ approval
for any audio- or video-taping of the mediation sessions.
-
Mediators should not regulate or control the
content of an agreement.
Ethical Principles for Mediators
Mediators should demonstrate:
-
Integrity
-
Objectivity and fairness
-
Intelligence and knowledge of the areas in
dispute
-
Emotional balance
-
Social perceptiveness
-
Written and oral communication skills
-
Patience
Mediators and Balancing Power
-
Do not make assumptions about the balance
or imbalance of power until doing case development work and observing behavior
in the first joint session.
-
Draw upon your character, credibility, and
integrity and a mediator to demonstrate fairness and voice. Communicate
these principles clearly.
Mediators and Balancing Power
-
Encourage the parties to share knowledge/information.
-
Use the parties’ desire to settle ass motivation.
-
Compensate for model or low negotiation skills.
Use questions and reframing to assist.
-
Interrupt intimidating negotiation or interaction
behaviors.
Mediators and Balancing Power
-
Make accommodations for differences in language
and culture.
-
Respect the needs (and anxieties) of the parties.
-
Encourage parties to voice underlying interests.
-
Do not rush to settlement.
-
Provide support for both/all parties.
-
Acknowledge constructive behavior.