Jay W. Pscheidt, OSU Extension Plant Pathology
Specialist
Fungicides are
best used to protect susceptible tissue in the spring at bud break
and for the next 8 weeks. Most fungicides will last 2 weeks before another
application is needed. This means a total of 4 applications starting with the
first at bud break. Although hazelnuts are still susceptible after this period,
additional applications have not resulted in significantly better disease
control.
Due to fungicide resistance issues and resulting label requirements, you
may not be able to use the same fungicide for all 4 applications. Since the EFB
fungus has a long 2-year life cycle the resistance risk is already low relative
to other diseases (such as powdery mildew). Strategies to minimize this risk
further include alternating and/or tank mixing fungicides with different modes of
action. The modes of action for fungicides have been categorized, grouped and
assigned numbers such as "group M5".
Alternating fungicides with different modes of action has been effective
to manage EFB. Research has not detected any one alternating strategy as better
than any other strategy. We have 4 fungicide groups to choose from including
groups 3, 11, M5 and M1. It is suggested that the first application be
chorothalonil (group M5) followed by your choice of a group 3 or 11 fungicide.
Each of the next two applications would be different from the last one. An
example of this program might be to start with Bravo (group M5) at bud break,
followed by Gem (group 11) two weeks later, then Tilt (group 3) two weeks after
that and ending with Cabrio (group 11). Use of multi-site products such as
chlorothalonil (M5) or copper-based (M1) products for all 4 applications would
also be acceptable.
Do not just alternate fungicides with different trade names as they might
have the same mode of action. Some fungicide premixes already are a combination
of two fungicides with different modes of action, generally a group 3 and 11
fungicide. These products cannot be used for every application as they do not
allow more than 2 sequential applications before switching to a different product
with a different mode of action. If you use these premixes you must use an M5 or
M1 fungicide in the rotation. An example of this program might be to start with
Bravo (M5) at bud break, followed by Adament (3 + 11) or QuiltXcel (3 + 11) 2
weeks later, then the same product 2 weeks after that but ending with Bravo.
You can make your own tank mixes. Since this can be expensive growers
have asked about reducing the rate of each product in the tank. Research to date
has shown that a half rate of Bravo tank mixed with either Tilt/Orbit (group 3)
or Cabrio (group 11) is effective to manage EFB. Combining fungicide resistance
theory and research on EFB in Oregon suggests we should use a half rate of
chlorothalonil tank mixed with a full rate of a group 3 fungicide or a half rate
of a group 11 fungicide. An example of this program might be:
1st Application - A full rate of Bravo (M5) at bud break.
2nd Application 2 weeks later - A mix of Cabrio (11) plus Bravo (M5) each at
half
rates.
3rd Application 2 weeks later - A mix of Tilt (3) at full rate plus Bravo (M5)
at
half rate.
4th Application 2 weeks later - A mix of Cabrio (11) plus Bravo (M5) each at
half
rates.
On going research has indicated that the addition of a surfactant may
provide better disease control than using a fungicide alone. Numerous products
can break the surface tension of water to get better coverage of plant tissue.
They also can help keep the fungicide solution in contact with the plant,
reducing wash off during rain events. Unless otherwise stated on the label, it is
recommended to add a surfactant with a fungicide. Copper-based products have
traditionally been applied with horticultural mineral oil. Newer fungicides may
be mixed with silicone-based or non-ionic surfactants. Be careful as several
fungicides may already come formulated with a surfactant and specifically say NOT
to add these products. For example, do not add a surfactant to Bravo, Echo or
Quadris Top.
Fungicides for
Control of Eastern Filbert Blight
Many
experiments have been conducted in the last 25 years to
evaluate fungicide effectiveness against Eastern Filbert
Blight (EFB). Dr. Ron Cameron directed several trials in
the late 1970's and early 1980's. Oregon State University
has also conducted a huge volume of laboratory,
greenhouse and field trials within the last 10
years.
Each of the tables generated for this summary list the
trade name of the product tested, rate of product used
per 100 gallons water, active ingredient, average number
of applications per season, average level of control and
total number of trials conducted. Trade names are those
used during the year the product was tested. Rates are in
product per 100 gallons water and are NOT
expressed in product per acre. In general, an equivalent
rate per acre for a mature orchard might be 2 to 4 times
the per 100 gallon rate. The percent control is based on
the number of cankers found per tree. For example, if a
non-treated tree had 10 cankers and a fungicide treated
tree had 1 canker then the fungicide applications
resulted in 90% control of EFB. The number in parenthesis
next to the total number of trials conducted indicates
the number of significant trials. In other words, the
number of trials where application of that material
resulted in control significantly better than no
application of fungicide at all.
Summary
Tables
Table
1 Registered
Materials
Table
2 Number of Bravo
720 applications needed
Table 2
per season for
control of EFB
Table
3
Demethylation-inhibiting Fungicides (DMI) for control of
EFB
Table
4 Combined Bravo
720 followed by DMI applications
Table
5 Strobilurin Fungicides for Control of EFB
Table
6 Miscellaneous
materials for the control of EFB
General Summary of Fungicide Group Effectiveness (pdf file)
Detailed Fungicide Research Reports
Information on the relative efficacy of fungicides, fungicide schedules or cultural practices for control of plant diseases such as EFB is generated each year. This more
detailed information can be found at the following web site:
The Fruit
and Ornamental Disease Management Testing Program